प्रजा अधीन राजा समूह | Right to Recall Group

अधिकार जैसे कि आम जन द्वारा भ्रष्ट को बदलने/सज़ा देने के अधिकार पर चर्चा करने के लिए मंच
It is currently Mon Aug 20, 2018 12:00 pm

All times are UTC + 5:30 hours


फोरम के नियम ; Forum rules


ये फोरम केवल कमेन्ट करने के लिए है ; यहाँ आप नया थ्रेड शुरू नहीं कर सकते | कृपया कमेन्ट करने से पहले फोरम के सारे नियम यहाँ पढ़ें - viewtopic.php?f=19&t=1098

This is a comment only forum. You cannot start a new thread here. Please read the rules of the forum before posting - viewtopic.php?f=19&t=1098



Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 9 posts ] 
SR. No. Author Message
1
PostPosted: Sun Feb 19, 2012 8:44 pm 
Offline

Joined: Mon Oct 17, 2011 2:53 am
Posts: 15
PLEASE READ ONLY LATEST VERSION RELATED TO THIS POST, AS MORE FLAWS CORRECTED.....................
benifits : immediate effect of TCP, Opportunity for organisations to directly work, rapid spread
disadv: may have complifications beacuse of non-govt movement.

pls discuss ,comment agree or disagree. PLEASE DONT IGNORE!! THANKS SHIVA


Attachments:
RTI2 or TCP intermediate measure 4 individual organisations or party..pdf [65.15 KiB]
Downloaded 330 times


Last edited by mail2shiva123atgmail on Fri Feb 24, 2012 4:20 am, edited 2 times in total.
Top
 Profile  
 
2
PostPosted: Sun Feb 19, 2012 10:15 pm 
Offline

Joined: Mon Oct 17, 2011 2:53 am
Posts: 15
was littlebit wrong. please see corrected version


Attachments:
RTI2 or TCP intermediate measure 4 individual organisations or party..doc [33.5 KiB]
Downloaded 316 times
RTI2 or TCP intermediate measure 4 individual organisations or party..pdf [70.04 KiB]
Downloaded 316 times
Top
 Profile  
 
3
PostPosted: Tue Feb 21, 2012 12:45 pm 
Offline

Joined: Mon Oct 17, 2011 2:53 am
Posts: 15
NEW VERSION...

added instruction so that
1.proxy is reduced.
2. legally sound
3. more stronger identifcation...

thanks for 13 view ... but comment and correct...
shiva


Attachments:
RTI2 or TCP intermediate measure 4 individual organisations or party.v1.01.pdf [78.96 KiB]
Downloaded 313 times
RTI2 or TCP intermediate measure 4 individual organisations or party.v1.01.doc [38.5 KiB]
Downloaded 311 times
Top
 Profile  
 
4
PostPosted: Tue Feb 21, 2012 11:27 pm 
Offline

Joined: Mon Oct 17, 2011 2:53 am
Posts: 15
TEXT AS SUGGESTED BY KMOKSHA

The draft of the proposed RTI2 law for volunteers /organisartions to bring until agreed by PM/CM/nationally.

There are three parts I, II, III, IV

I=The draft of the proposed RTI2 law as by rahul mehtha

which should be read from http://rahulmehta.com/001.pdf.

IT IS NOT AVALABLE BELOW BUT IT IS BACKBONE , SO FOLLOWING APPLIES ONLY AFTER PART1 IN THE ABOVE LINK. It explains draft to be signed by PM or CM. Following part II and III are only INTERMEDIATE MEASURE untill part I is done. Part II and III will vanish as soon as CM/PM signs part I.

II= Request to for individuals/ organizations /political parties (now on called as IOP )

who promotes transparent complaint procedure(TCP=RTI2) and hopes to get support from Right to recall /TCP activists to improve India.

III=Modified draft for IOP to do until I is implemented.

IV= Instructions to all involved


================

I. Read draft from http://rahulmehta.com/001.pdf

II. Request to IOP(Individuals/Organisations/Political Parties) to promote RTI2=TCP

A. IOP(Individuals/Organisations/Political Parties) will

1.Write to PM and CM asking them to pass a resolution and/or print the above (http://rahulmehta.com/001.pdf ) RTI2=TCP clauses in the gazette notification. Also s/he will post the copy of this letter to mayor/CM on his facebook and similar websites.

B. If draft is not signed by PM/CM within 10 days of the letter of request, IOP(Individuals/Organisations/Political Parties) will open same opportunity in any official website under their power.


C. If the IOP’s request is not honored by PM/CM/the govt bodies

Open their own private website and put below find modified draft’s suitable for particular geographical area, like district / village panchayat or constituency. They will privately fund one clerk (called now on as PFC=privately funded clerk) working 3 days a week, 8am to 5 pm to implement this modified draft.

This modified draft is intermediate staged proposal which will be replaced by State Govt Gazette Notification draft when implemented by CM and other govt bodies.


III. Modified Draft for RTI2 law for Individuals/organizations/political parties to bring until agreed by PM/CM/nationally.


#
(Officer)
Procedure / instruction

1 (IOP=Individuals/Organisations/Political Parties, PFC=Private Funded Clerk)

If a woman voter or dalit voter or senior citizen voter or
poor voter or farmer voter or ANY citizen-voter submits a suggestion / general complaint without targeting individuals or organizations/ political party , or anyone- as an affidavit and demands to be put on website of IOP, with his name and voter ID number. IOP or PFC will issue a serial number and put scanned copy, name,city,voter ID number on IOP’s website for fee of Rs 20 per page .

2 (IOP=Individuals/Organisations/Political Parties, PFC=Private Funded Clerk)

If a woman voter or a dalit voter or a senior citizen voter or a
poor voter or a farmer voter or ANY citizen-voter comes with voter ID, and specifies to put his name, voter ID number,Yes-No on an above (clause #1) affidavit, the IOP/PFC will enter his Yes-No on the website with name and voter-ID and give a printed receipt for Rs 3 fee. IOP /PFC will also allow citizen to change his Yes-No for Rs 3 fee. The fee will be Re 1 for BPL card holder.

3 (All citizen voters)

Any of the citizen coming to IOP’s office can video record the event. (this is to ensure IOP doesn’t avoid unfavourable complaints). Any affending statement (ex- targeting an individual) – scanned copy should still be put on the website- but by deleting controversial / identification part using a black pen.

IV. Instructions to all involved


Instructions for citizen demanding to publish statement :

1.all pages should be numberd ex: 1 of 5 pages,4 of 5 pages.
2.all pages should have sign, thumb impression and dated in presence of IOP or PFC.
3. sign should match voter ID sign
4.Last page has scanned copy of voter id and space for taking a photo in IOP office
5. it also has a declaration to publish your name, voter id card copy, photo and statement in public , to store your details, and your legal responsibility to the contents of the statement, process cosequences.

Instructions for IOP/PFC

1. In the last page of statement, Take photo of the citizen holding his voter ID on his side of the face. Print this photo next to voter id scanned page. (For better comparison of voter id scanned page and miniature voter id in the photo, they should come next to each other). ask citizens to sign , thumb impression date both on the photo and below it so that you could defend if legally challenged.

Followed by, State you are responsible for identification of the person but not for his statement and you have identified the person , sign date and thumb impress.

2. Photocopy whole statement-sign, thumb impress date all pages, and give copy to the citizen. Keep original with you.

3. Decide whether contents are not controversial, you can defend if legally claimed, and not defaming any person/organization/ society/ group or anything. If so , publish.

If controversial – photocopy again, on the photocopy hide (ex:by blackmarking with a black sketchpen) information – which you think will defame as much and as less as required.

Scan this photocopy and publish the statement. (now any one can read half of the content- but defamory part is not readble) . keep original with you.

4. publish the scanned copy of statement in 24 hours of receiving. (if the office is not working for 24 hours or you expect too busy to publish- state at very beginning of the process , don’t start process and ask citizen to come later ).

Instructions to the IOP/PFC related to citizens demanding to publish Yes/no:

On their letter capture a picture of their passport photo, asking them to hold their voter id next to face , once done, ask them to sign, thumb impress ,date. After this step, you state that you are responsible for confirming the person and stated voter id, sign, thumb impress and date it.

Instructions for citizen demanding to publish YES /NO:

provide IOP/PFC a letter stating

1. your consent and demand to publish name, voter id, yes/no
2. your mobile number if you have one and like to be eligible to say yes/no for other statements through mobile at later stage. (Note: having a mobile number is not compulsory- it may add convenience in later stages to give your yes/no opinions.)
3. Give consent to store your details.
4. has scanned copy of your voter ID
5. you agree that -one person can register once, and should not come with different part of name, id and try to duplicate.

(Version 1.01 21/02/2012 # I= initial author Rahul Mehta, #II.III modifications by Shiva thippaiah. You are free to change draft. It will be supported by me (Shiva), if >70% of previous supporters agree on changes. This is just an idea. Authors are not suggesting/forcing any individual/organisation /political party to implement it OR to respond to such process nor responsible for any legal issues, if done.)


Attachments:
RTI2 or TCP intermediate measure 4 individual organisations or party..pdf [70.04 KiB]
Downloaded 300 times
RTI2 or TCP intermediate measure 4 individual organisations or party..doc [33.5 KiB]
Downloaded 319 times


Last edited by mail2shiva123atgmail on Wed Feb 22, 2012 4:21 am, edited 1 time in total.
Top
 Profile  
 
5
PostPosted: Wed Feb 22, 2012 4:12 am 
Offline

Joined: Mon Oct 17, 2011 2:53 am
Posts: 15

The draft of the proposed RTI2 law for volunteers /organizations to bring until agreed by PM/CM/nationally.


There are four parts I, II, III, IV

I=the explanation of draft of the proposed RTI2 law as by rahul Mehta which should be read from http://rahulmehta.com/001.pdf.

II= Request to individuals/ organizations /political parties (now on called as IOP)

who promotes transparent complaint procedure (TCP=RTI2) and hopes to get support from Right to recall /TCP activists to improve India.

III=Modified draft for IOP to do until I is implemented.

IV= Instructions to all involved

I.
Read explanation of draft from http://rahulmehta.com/001.pdf

CITIZENS VOICE Transparent Complaint Procedure Gazette notification

1) if a woman voter or dalit
voter or senior citizen voter or poor voter or farmer voter or ANY citizen- voter in his district submits a Right to Information application or complaint against corruption or any affidavit to the Collector and requests to be put on the website of Prime Minister, the Collector or his designated clerk will issue a serial number and put that affidavit etc on the website of the Prime Minister for a fee of Rs 20 per page.

2) if a woman voter or a dalit voter or a , senior citizen voter or a poor voter or a farmer voter or ANY citizen-voter , comes with voter ID, and specifies Yes-No on an RTI application, complaint or any affidavit submitted in clause-1, the Patwari will enter his Officer Yes-No on the PM‟s website with his voter-ID and give a printed receipt for Rs 3 fee.

2A) The Patwari will also allow citizen to change his Yes-No for Rs 3 fee any day. The fee will be Re 1 for BPL card holder.

3) This CITIZENS`VOICE/JANTA KI AWAZ GN is not a referendum procedure. The Yes-No count will not be a binding on PM, CMs, officers, If over 37 crore women voters, dalit voters, senior citizen voters, poor voters, farmer voters or ANY 37 crore citizen-voters register Yes on a given affidavit, then the PM may or need not take necessary action on the RTI application affidavit ; or the PM may or need not resign. PM‟s decision will be final.

I summarize the CITIZENS`VOICE Transparent complaint procedure gazette-notification law as
o If a citizen wants, then by visiting Collector‟s office, he can put Complaint/RTI application/Proposal on PM‟s website.
o If a citizen supports an application, complain etc, then by visiting Talati‟s (Patwari etc) office,
citizen can register his support to an Complaint/RTI application/Proposal on PM`s website for a Rs 3/- fee.

This transparent complaint procedure will ensure that the citizens` complaint is VISIBLE and VERIFIABLE by anyone, anywhere and anytime so that the complaint cannot be suppressed by the politicians, officials(lokpal etc), judges or media.


This part I is the BACKBONE, SO FOLLOWING APPLIES ONLY AFTER PART1 IN THE ABOVE LINK. Proposal in this link explains draft to be signed by PM or CM. Following part II and III are only INTERMEDIATE MEASURE until part I is done. Part II and III will vanish as soon as CM/PM signs part I.

II. Request to IOP to promote RTI2=TCP


A. IOP (Individual/Organisations/Political Parties) will

1. Write to PM and CM asking them to pass a resolution and/or print the above (http://rahulmehta.com/001.pdf ) RTI2=TCP clauses in the gazette notification. Also s/he will post the copy of this letter to mayor/CM on his facebook and similar websites.

B. If draft is not signed by PM/CM within 10 days of the letter of request, IOP will open same opportunity in any official website under their power.


C. If the IOP’s request is not honored by PM/CM/the govt bodies

Open their own private website and put below find modified draft’s suitable for particular geographical area, like district / village panchayath or constituency. They will privately fund one clerk (called now on as PFC=privately funded clerk) working 3 days a week, 8am to 5 pm to implement this modified draft.

This modified draft is intermediate staged proposal which will be replaced by State Govt Gazette Notification draft when implemented by CM and other govt bodies.


III. Modified Draft for RTI2 law for Individuals/organizations/political parties to bring until agreed by PM/CM/nationally.



# (Officer)
Procedure / instruction

1 (IOP=Individuals/Organisations/Political Parties, PFC=Privately funded Clerk)

If a woman voter or dalit voter or senior citizen voter or
Poor voter or farmer voter or ANY citizen-voter submits a suggestion / general complaint without targeting individuals or organizations/ political party, or anyone- as an affidavit and demands to be put on website of IOP, with his name and voter ID number. IOP or PFC will issue a serial number and put scanned copy, name, city, voter ID number on IOP’s website for fee of Rs 20 per page.

2 (IOP=Individuals/Organisations/Political Parties, PFC=Privately funded Clerk)

If a woman voter or a dalit voter or a senior citizen voter or a
poor voter or a farmer voter or ANY citizen-voter comes with voter ID, and specifies to put his name, voter ID number, Yes-No on an above (clause #1) affidavit, the IOP/PFC will enter his Yes-No on the website with name and voter-ID and give a printed receipt for Rs 3 fee. IOP /PFC will also allow citizen.
To change his Yes-No for Rs 3 fee. The fee will be Re 1 for BPL card holder

3 (All)

Any of the citizens coming to IOP’s office can video record the event. (This is to ensure IOP doesn’t avoid unfavorable complaints). Any offending statement , if the website owner so decides (ex- targeting an individual) – scanned copy should still be put on the website- but by deleting controversial / identification part using a black pen and keeping a backup of the original.*

* The citizen voter can file statements in as many private websites as he likes so as to rule out any wrong ,biased blocking of the statement by a particular private website owner.

IV. Instructions to all involved

Instructions for citizen demanding to publish statement:

1. All pages should be numbered ex: 1 of 5 pages, 4 of 5 pages.
2. All pages should have sign, thumb impression and dated in presence of IOP or PFC.
3. Sign should match voter ID sign
4. Last page has scanned copy of voter id and space for taking a photo in IOP office
5. It also has a declaration to publish your name, voter ID card copy, photo and statement in public, to store your details, and your legal responsibility to the contents of the statement, process consequences.

Instructions for IOP/PFC


1. In the last page of statement, take photo of the citizen holding his voter ID on his side of the face. Print this photo next to voter id scanned page. (For better comparison of voter id scanned page and miniature voter id in the photo, they should come next to each other). Ask citizens to sign, thumb impression date both on the photo and below it so that you could defend if legally challenged.

Followed by, State you are responsible for identification of the person but not for his statement and you have identified the person, sign date and thumb impress.

2. Photocopy whole statement-sign, thumb impress date all pages, and give copy to the citizen. Keep original with you.

3. Decide the contents are not controversial; cause no defamation to anyone/organization/ society/ group or anything. Decide you can defend if legally claimed. If so, publish.

If controversial – photocopy again, on the photocopy hide (ex: by black marking with a black sketch pen) defamation causing information as much and as less as required. Scan this photocopy and publish the statement. (Now any one can read half of the content- but defamatory part is not readable). Keep original with you. Never put controversial statement in publication. Controversial material is for later stages- when agreed by PM/CM.)

4. Publish the scanned copy of statement in 24 hours of receiving. (If the office is not working for 24 hours or you expect too busy to publish- state at very beginning of the process, don’t start process and ask citizen to come later).

Instructions to the IOP/PFC related to citizens demanding to publish Yes/no:

On their letter capture a picture of their passport photo, asking them to hold their voter id next to face, once done, ask them to sign, thumb impress, date. After this step, you state that you are responsible for confirming the person and stated voter id, sign, thumb impress and date it.

Instructions for citizen demanding to publish YES /NO:


Provide IOP/PFC a letter stating

1. Your consent and demand to publish name, voter id, yes/no
2. Your mobile number if you have one and like to be eligible to say yes/no for other statements through mobile at later stage. (Note: having a mobile number is not compulsory- it may add convenience in later stages to give your yes/no opinions.)
3. Give consent to store your details.
4. Has scanned copy of your voter ID
5. You agree that -one person can register once, and should not come with different part of name, id and try to duplicate.

(Version 1.02 21/02/2012 # I= initial author Rahul Mehta, #II-IV modifications by Shiva thippaiah. You are free to change draft. It will be supported by me (Shiva), if >70% of previous supporters agree on changes. This is just an idea. Authors are not suggesting/forcing any individual/organization /political party to implement it nor to respond to such process nor responsible for any legal issues, if done.)


Attachments:
TCP intermediate measure 4 individual organisations or party.v1.02.doc [46 KiB]
Downloaded 317 times
TCP intermediate measure 4 individual organisations or party.v1.02.pdf [114.33 KiB]
Downloaded 329 times


Last edited by kmoksha on Sat Feb 25, 2012 11:54 pm, edited 3 times in total.
Edited the text of the draft- kmoksha
Top
 Profile  
 
6
PostPosted: Sun Feb 26, 2012 8:57 pm 
Offline

Joined: Mon Oct 17, 2011 2:53 am
Posts: 15
if you want to correct any little thing update and say next version and update- so that activists always able to edit most updated version. thanks . shiva
------------------------------------------------------------------------
contents are same in below/word/pdf
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
The draft of the proposed Transparent Complaint Procedure (TCP) law for volunteers /organizations to bring until agreed by PM/CM/nationally.
There are four parts I, II, III, IV
I=the draft of the proposed TCP law as by Rahul Mehta . Detailed explanation should be read from http://righttorecall.info/001.pdf.
II= Request to individuals/ organizations /political parties (now on called as IOP) who promotes transparent complaint procedure (TCP) and hopes to get support from Right to recall /TCP activists to improve India.
III=Modified draft for IOP to do until I is implemented.
IV= Instructions to all involved
==================================================================
I. Full draft
#
Officer
Procedure
1
Collector
(or his clerk)
If a woman voter or dalit voter or senior citizen voter or poor voter or farmer voter or ANY citizen-submits a Right to Information application or complaint against corruption or any affidavit to Collector and demands to be put on the website of the Prime Minister, the Collector or his clerk issue a serial number and put it on PM’s website for a fee of Rs 20 per page.
2
Civic Center Clerk /Village Officer
(or his clerk)
If a woman voter or a dalit voter or a senior citizen voter or a poor voter or a farmer voter or ANY citizen-voter comes with voter ID, and specifies Yes-No on an RTI application, complaint or any affidavit submitted in cluase-1, the Village Officer/Civic Center Clerk will enter his Yes-No on the PM’s website with his voter-ID and give a printed receipt for Rs 3 fee. The Village Officer/Civic Center Clerk will allow citizen to change his Yes-No for Rs 3 fee. The fee will be Re 1 for BPL card holder
3
----
This is not a referendum procedure .The Yes-No count will not be a binding on PM, CMs, officers, judges etc. Though if over 37 crores women voters, dalit voters, senior citizen voters, poor voters, farmer voters or ANY 37 crore citizen-voters register Yes on a given affidavit, then the PM may or need take necessary action on the RTI application affidavit ; or the PM may or need not resign. PM’s decision will be final.
I summarize the CITIZENS VOICE / JANTA KI AWAZ law as
 If a citizen wants, then by visiting Collector’s office, he can put his RTI application etc on PM’s website Rs 20 fee.
 If a citizen supports and RTI application, complain etc, then by visiting Village Officer/Civic Center Clerk’s (Lekhpal, Patwari etc) office, he can register his support (YES) over an RTI application etc on PM’s website for Rs 3/- fee.
 The YES-count is not a binding on PM etc.
Please read the same draft along with explanation of the draft in http://righttorecall.info/001.pdf
It is the BACKBONE, SO FOLLOWING APPLIES ONLY AFTER PART1 IN THE ABOVE LINK. Proposal in this link explains draft to be signed by PM or CM. Following part II and III are only INTERMEDIATE MEASURE until part I is done. Part II and III will vanish as soon as CM/PM signs part I.
II. Request to IOP(Individuals/Organisations/Political Parties) to promote TCP (Transparent Complaint / Proposal Procedure)
A. IOP will
1. Write to PM and CM asking them to pass a resolution and/or print the above (http://righttorecall.info/001.pdf ) RTI2=TCP clauses in the gazette notification. Also s/he will post the copy of this letter to mayor/CM on his facebook and similar websites.
B. If draft is not signed by PM/CM within 10 days of the letter of request, IOP will open same opportunity in any official website under their power.
C. If the IOP’s request is not honored by PM/CM/the govt bodies
Open their own private website and put below find modified draft’s suitable for particular geographical area, like district / village panchayath or constituency. They will privately fund one clerk (called now on as PFC=privately funded clerk) working 3 days a week, 8am to 5 pm to implement this modified draft.
This modified draft is intermediate staged proposal which will be replaced by State Govt Gazette Notification draft when implemented by CM and other govt bodies.
Modified Draft for RTI2 law for Individuals/organizations/political parties to bring until agreed by PM/CM/nationally.
#
Officer
Procedure / instruction
1
IOP (Individual/Organisation/Political Party)
If ANY citizen-voter (can be a woman/dalit /senior citizen/Poor /farmer voter ) submits a suggestion / general complaint without targeting individuals or organizations/ political party, or anyone- as an affidavit and demands to be put on website of IOP, with his name and voter ID
PFC(Private Funded Clerk)
number. IOP or PFC will issue a serial number and put scanned copy, name, city, voter ID number on IOP’s website for fee of Rs 20 per page.
2
IOP (Individual/Organisation/Political Party)
PFC(Private Funded Clerk)
If ANY citizen-voter (can be a woman/dalit /senior citizen/Poor /farmer voter ) comes with voter ID, and specifies to put his/her name, voter ID number, Yes-No on an above (clause #1) affidavit, the IOP/PFC will enter his/her Yes-No on the website with name and voter-ID and give a printed receipt for Rs 5 fee. IOP /PFC will also allow citizen
To change his/her Yes-No for Rs 5 fee. The fee will be Re 1 for BPL card holder , I want to delete this
3
All
Any of the citizens coming to IOP’s office can video record the event. (This is to ensure IOP doesn’t avoid unfavorable complaints). Any offending statement (ex- targeting an individual) – scanned copy should still be put on the website- but by deleting controversial / identification part using a black pen and keeping a backup of the original.*
* The citizen voter can file statements in as many private websites of IOP as he likes so as to rule out any wrong , biased blocking of the statement by a particular private website owner .
IV. Instructions to all involved
Instructions for citizen demanding to publish statement:
1. All pages should be numbered ex: 1 of 5 pages, 4 of 5 pages.
2. All pages should have sign, thumb impression and dated in presence of IOP or PFC.
3. voters image and sign on voter ID should match the person .
4. Last page has scanned copy of voter id and space for taking a photo in IOP office
5. It also has a declaration to publish your name, voter ID card copy, photo and statement in public, to store your details, and your legal responsibility to the contents of the statement, process, consequences.
6.Heading- write what outcome you want to achieve
7. write , according to you, who(officer/politician/organisation) is responsible to bring this action?
8. Mention any other IOP website you/any other citizen have already put the same content or not. If the complaint has same content but re-asked by you in this region ( because you found the content is very relavent for the local population as well) and say you found the parent content in Bangalore IOP with complaint number 560003-04-0010pd,also you are aware that it is also copied 4 times so far in
Chennai, delhi, culcatta and Mumbai, then you should mention “copied content no5 parent document in complaint number560003-04-0010 and write this in short form as cc05-560003-04-0010pd”
Instructions for IOP (Individual/Organisation/Political Party)/PFC(Private Funded Clerk)
1. In the last page of statement, take photo of the citizen holding his voter ID on his side of the face. Print this photo next to voter id scanned page. (For better comparison of voter id scanned page and miniature voter id in the photo, they should come next to each other). Ask citizens to sign, thumb impression, date
a. on the photo(sign , thumb impression and date should be situated half on the right upper part of photo, and the other half on the paper.)
b. below the photo
so that you could defend if legally challenged
2. Followed by, State you are responsible for identification of the voter ( but not for his statement) and voter has displayed his voter ID, allowed to capture his photo and sign date and thumb impressed in your presence. Now you sign, thumb impress, date below the photo and below the voters sign
Photocopy whole statement- thumb impress, sign, date all pages, and give a photocopy to the citizen. Keep original with you.
3. Decide the contents are not controversial; cause no defamation to anyone/organization/ society/ group or anything. Decide you can defend if legally claimed. If so, publish.
If controversial – photocopy again, on the photocopy hide (ex: by black marking with a black sketch pen) defamation causing information as much and as less as required. Scan this photocopy and publish the statement. (Now any one can read half of the content- but defamatory part is not readable). Keep original with you. Never put controversial statement in publication. Controversial material is for later stages- when agreed by PM/CM.)
4. Publish the scanned copy of statement in 24 hours of receiving. (If the office is not working for 24 hours or you expect too busy to publish- state at very beginning of the process, don’t start process and ask citizen to come later).
5. We recommend IOP should cover only the place which is feasible for citizens to come to your office to put either complaint or YES/NO.
6. Please name your IOP Website as in this example. If your office covers Bangalore 1 and Bangalore 2, we know Bangalore pin is 560001 and there are already 5 IOP websites are available as you know, then your IOP name will be 560001-02-006
7. Name each complaint as in these eg : If 49th complaint is put in your IOP office and complainer says it is not copied from anywhere then complaint number will become 560001-02-006-0049 pd
(here pd = parental document)
Second eg : If 50th complaint is put in your IOP office, but complainer citizen says “it is repetition, in fact it is 5th repetition of content and parent document is from the complaint number560003-04-0010pd and writes this in short form as cc05-560003-04-0010pd”then his complaint number will be 560001-02-006-0050-cc05-560003-04-0010pd.
8. Instructions to the IOP/PFC related to citizens demanding to publish Yes/no:
On their letter capture a picture of their passport photo, asking them to hold their voter id next to face, once done, ask them to sign, thumb impress, date. After this step, you state that you are responsible for confirming the person and stated voter id, sign, thumb impress and date it.
Instructions for citizen demanding to publish YES /NO:
Please read , Provide IOP (Individual/Organisation/Political Party)/PFC(Private Funded Clerk)
this letter if you agree with content
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
To IOP (Individual/Organisation/Political Party)/PFC(Private Funded Clerk)
complaint number 560001-02-006-0050-cc05-560003-04-0010pd
first wordings of the complaint ---------------------------------------------------
(Delete one not applicable.) I support the above complaint. I oppose above complaint.
Name as per in voter id: first name ---------------------------------------------------------------------surname ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Voter id number……………………………………………………..
I consent and demand to publish name, voter id and my opinion of yes/no. I am aware of consequences.
SPACE TO PHOTOCOPY VOTER ID – SPACE TO TAKE PHOTO
SPACE TO THUMB IMPRESS AND SIGN AND DATE
SPACE TO THUMB IMPRESS AND SIGN AND DATE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------(info to IOP/fold and scan above, put it in website)
1. (Delete which don’t apply to you)
A. I give consent to display my mobile number in public. My mobile no -------------------------.
C.I would like to be eligible to say yes or no for other future statements through mobile at later stage. (Note: having a mobile number is not compulsory- it may add convenience in later stages to give your yes/no opinions when robust identification method is designed or when part 1 is accomplished.)
D. I don’t want to provide my mobile number
E. I provide mobile number – only for communication between you and me. Don’t publish it . my mobile no -------------------------
3. I give consent to store my details
4. I have photocopied my voter ID
5. I agree that one person should register only once in one IOP office and should not come with different part of name, id and try to duplicate.
6. If same contented complaint is asked by same/other complainer and displayed by different IOP website, I will not put my yes/no there, so that duplicate opinion is avoided for that particular complaint.
Thumb impression and Sign date place
Info to IOP/PFC : Photocopy, thumb impress,sign date the photocopy give it YES/NO citizen. Keep original with IOP office.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------(Version 1.03 26/02/2012 # I= initial author Rahul Mehta, #II-IV modifications by RRG. You are free to change draft. It will be supported by RRG, if >70% of previous supporters agree on changes. This is just an idea. Authors are not suggesting/forcing any individual/organization /political party to implement it nor to respond to such process nor responsible for any legal issues, if done


Attachments:
TCP intermediate measure 4 individual organisations or party.v1.03 26022012.pdf [159.32 KiB]
Downloaded 313 times
TCP intermediate measure 4 individual organisations or party.v1.03 26022012.doc [53 KiB]
Downloaded 329 times
Top
 Profile  
 
7
PostPosted: Thu Mar 01, 2012 10:56 pm 
Offline

Joined: Sun Sep 12, 2010 2:49 pm
Posts: 596
Shiva,

Made the changes and uploaded doc file version 1.04.
The changes are in colour or highlighted (in doc file)

==================================

The draft of the proposed Transparent Complaint Procedure (TCP) law for volunteers /organizations to bring until agreed by PM/CM/nationally.


There are four parts I, II, III, IV
I=the draft of the proposed TCP law as by Rahul Mehta . Detailed explanation should be read from http://righttorecall.info/001.pdf.
II= Request to individuals/ organizations /political parties (now on called as IOP) who promotes transparent complaint procedure (TCP) and hopes to get support from Right to recall /TCP activists to improve India.
III=Modified draft for IOP to do until I is implemented.
IV= Instructions to all involved

==================================================================

I. Full draft

#
Officer Procedure

1 Collector

(or his clerk) If a woman voter or dalit voter or senior citizen voter or poor voter or farmer voter or ANY citizen-voter submits a Right to Information application or complaint against corruption or any affidavit to the Collector and demands to be put on the website of the Prime Minister by scanning , the Collector or his clerk will issue a serial number and put it on PM’s website for a fee of Rs 20 per page.

2 Civic Center Clerk /Village Officer

(or his clerk) If a woman voter or a dalit voter or a senior citizen voter or a poor voter or a farmer voter or ANY citizen-voter comes with voter ID, and specifies Yes-No on an RTI application, complaint or any affidavit submitted in cluase-1, the Village Officer/Civic Center Clerk will enter his Yes-No on the PM’s website with his voter-ID and give a printed receipt for Rs 3 fee. The Village Officer/Civic Center Clerk will also allow citizen to change his Yes-No for Rs 3 fee. The fee will be Re 1 for BPL card holder

3 ---- This is not a referendum procedure .The Yes-No count will not be a binding on PM, CMs, officers, judges etc. Though if over 37 crores women voters, dalit voters, senior citizen voters, poor voters, farmer voters or ANY 37 crore citizen-voters register Yes on a given affidavit, then the PM may or need not take necessary action on the RTI application affidavit ; or the PM may or need not resign. PM’s decision will be final.

I summarize the CITIZENS VOICE / JANTA KI AWAZ law as
• If a citizen wants, then by visiting Collector’s office, he can put his RTI application etc on PM’s website Rs 20 fee.
• If a citizen supports and RTI application, complain etc, then by visiting Village Officer/Civic Center Clerk’s (Lekhpal, Patwari etc) office, he can register his support (YES) over an RTI application etc on PM’s website for Rs 3/- fee.
• The YES-count is not a binding on PM etc.

Please read the same draft along with explanation of the draft in http://righttorecall.info/001.pdf

It is the BACKBONE, SO FOLLOWING APPLIES ONLY AFTER PART1 IN THE ABOVE LINK. Proposal in this link explains draft to be signed by PM or CM. Following part II and III are only INTERMEDIATE MEASURE until part I is done. Part II and III will vanish as soon as CM/PM signs part I.

II. Request to IOP(Individuals/Organisations/Political Parties) to promote TCP (Transparent Complaint / Proposal Procedure)

A. IOP will

1. Write to PM and CM asking them to pass a resolution and/or print the above (http://righttorecall.info/001.pdf ) RTI2=TCP clauses in the gazette notification. Also s/he will post the copy of this letter to mayor/CM on his facebook and similar websites.

B. If draft is not signed by PM/CM within 10 days of the letter of request, IOP will open same opportunity in any official website under their power.


C. If the IOP’s request is not honored by PM/CM/the govt bodies
Open their own private website and put below find modified draft’s suitable for particular geographical area, like district / village panchayath or constituency. They will privately fund one clerk (called now on as PFC=privately funded clerk) working 3 days a week, 8am to 5 pm to implement this modified draft.

This modified draft is intermediate staged proposal which will be replaced by State Govt Gazette Notification draft when implemented by CM and other govt bodies.


Modified Draft for RTI2 law for Individuals/organizations/political parties to bring until agreed by PM/CM/nationally.


# Officer Procedure / instruction

1 IOP (Individual/Organisation/Political Party)
PFC(Private Funded Clerk) If ANY citizen-voter (can be a woman/dalit /senior citizen/Poor /farmer voter ) submits a suggestion / general complaint without targeting individuals or organizations/ political party, or anyone- as an affidavit and demands to be put on website of IOP, with his name and voter ID number. IOP or PFC will issue a serial number and put scanned copy, name, city, voter ID number on IOP’s website for fee of Rs 20 per page.

2 IOP (Individual/Organisation/Political Party)
PFC(Private Funded Clerk) If ANY citizen-voter (can be a woman/dalit /senior citizen/Poor /farmer voter ) comes with voter ID, and specifies to put his/her name, voter ID number, Yes-No on an above (clause #1) affidavit, the IOP/PFC will enter his/her Yes-No on the website with name and voter-ID and give a printed receipt for Rs 5 fee. IOP /PFC will also allow citizen

To change his/her Yes-No for Rs 5 fee. The fee will be Re 1 for BPL card holder -keep

3 All Any of the citizens coming to IOP’s office can video record the event. (This is to ensure IOP doesn’t avoid unfavorable complaints). Any offending statement (ex- targeting an individual) – scanned copy should still be put on the website- but by deleting controversial / identification part using a black pen and keeping a backup of the original.*

* The citizen voter can file statements in as many private websites of IOP as he likes so as to rule out any wrong , biased blocking of the statement by a particular private website owner

IV. Instructions to all involved


Instructions for citizen demanding to publish statement:

1. All pages should be numbered ex: 1 of 5 pages, 4 of 5 pages on a affidavit

2. All pages should have sign, thumb impression and dated in presence of IOP or PFC.

3. voters image and sign on voter ID should match the person .

4. Last page has scanned copy of voter id and space for taking a photo in IOP office

5. It also has a declaration to publish your name, voter ID card copy, photo and statement in public, to store your details, and your legal responsibility to the contents of the statement, process, consequences.

6.Heading- write what outcome you want to achieve- delete

7. write , according to you, who(officer/politician/organisation) is responsible to bring this action?

8. Mention any other IOP website you/any other citizen have already put the same content or not. If the complaint has same content but re-asked by you in this region ( because you found the content is very relavent for the local population as well) and say you found the parent content in Bangalore IOP with complaint number 560003-04-0010pd,also you are aware that it is also copied 4 times so far in Chennai, delhi, culcatta and Mumbai, then you should mention “copied content no5 parent document in complaint number560003-04-0010 and write this in short form as cc05-560003-04-0010pd”

Instructions for IOP (Individual/Organisation/Political Party)/PFC(Private Funded Clerk)

1. In the last page of statement, take photo of the citizen holding his voter ID on his side of the face. Print this photo next to voter id scanned page. (For better comparison of voter id scanned page and miniature voter id in the photo, they should come next to each other). Ask citizens to sign/thumb impress, give fingerprint scan, date

a. on the photo(sign , thumb impression and date should be situated half on the right upper part of photo, and the other half on the paper.)
b. below the photo
so that you could defend if legally challenged

2. Followed by, State you are responsible for identification of the voter ( but not for his statement) and voter has displayed his voter ID, allowed to capture his photo and sign/thumb impress, take fingerprint scan and date in your presence. Now you put sign, date below the photo and below the voters sign
Photocopy whole statement- thumb impress/ sign, date all pages, and give a photocopy to the citizen. Keep original with you.


3. Decide the contents are not controversial; cause no defamation to anyone/organization/ society/ group or anything. Decide you can defend if legally claimed. If so, publish.

If controversial – photocopy again, on the photocopy hide (ex: by black marking with a black sketch pen) defamation causing information as much and as less as required. Scan this photocopy and publish the statement. (Now any one can read half of the content- but defamatory part is not readable). Keep original with you. Never put controversial statement in publication. Controversial material is for later stages- when agreed by PM/CM.)

4. Publish the scanned copy of statement in 24 hours of receiving. (If the office is not working for 24 hours or you expect too busy to publish- state at very beginning of the process, don’t start process and ask citizen to come later).

5. We recommend IOP should cover only the place which is feasible for citizens to come to your office to put either complaint or YES/NO.

6. Please name your IOP Website as in this example. If your office covers Bangalore 1 and Bangalore 2, we know Bangalore pin is 560001 and there are already 5 IOP websites are available as you know, then your IOP name will be 560001-02-006

7. Name each complaint as in these eg : If 49th complaint is put in your IOP office and complainer says it is not copied from anywhere then complaint number will become 560001-02-006-0049 pd
(here pd = parental document)

Second eg : If 50th complaint is put in your IOP office, but complainer citizen says “it is repetition, in fact it is 5th repetition of content and parent document is from the complaint number560003-04-0010pd and writes this in short form as cc05-560003-04-0010pd”then his complaint number will be 560001-02-006-0050-cc05-560003-04-0010pd.

8. Instructions to the IOP/PFC related to citizens demanding to publish Yes/no:
On their letter capture a picture of their passport photo, asking them to hold their voter id next to face, once done, ask them to sign, thumb impress, date. After this step, you state that you are responsible for confirming the person and stated voter id, sign, thumb impress and date it.

Instructions for citizen demanding to publish YES /NO:
Please read , Provide IOP (Individual/Organisation/Political Party)/PFC(Private Funded Clerk)
this letter if you agree with content

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
To IOP (Individual/Organisation/Political Party)/PFC(Private Funded Clerk)
complaint number 560001-02-006-0050-cc05-560003-04-0010pd
first wordings of the complaint ---------------------------------------------------
(Delete one not applicable.) I support the above complaint. I oppose above complaint.
Name as per in voter id: first name ---------------------------------------------------------------------surname ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Voter id number……………………………………………………..
I consent and demand to publish name, voter id and my opinion of yes/no. I am aware of consequences.
SPACE TO PHOTOCOPY VOTER ID – SPACE TO TAKE PHOTO



SPACE TO THUMB IMPRESS AND SIGN AND DATE
SPACE TO THUMB IMPRESS AND SIGN AND DATE

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------(info to IOP/fold and scan above, put it in website)
1. (Tick option which applies to you)

A. I give consent to display my mobile number in public. My mobile no -------------------------.
B.I would like to be eligible to say yes or no for other future statements through mobile at later stage. (Note: having a mobile number is not compulsory- it may add convenience in later stages to give your yes/no opinions when robust identification method is designed or when part 1 is accomplished.)

C. I don’t want to provide my mobile number

D. I provide mobile number – only for communication between you and me. Don’t publish it . my mobile no -------------------------

2. I will activate my registration by sending a sms from the said mobile to _____ (service number to be given by IOP)

3. I give consent to store my details

4. I have photocopied my voter ID

5. I agree that one person should register only once in one IOP office and should not come with different part of name, id and try to duplicate.

6. If same contented complaint is asked by same/other complainer and displayed by different IOP website, I will not put my yes/no there, so that duplicate opinion is avoided for that particular complaint.

Thumb impression and Sign date place
Info to IOP/PFC : Photocopy, thumb impress,sign date the photocopy give it YES/NO citizen. Keep original with IOP office.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------(Version 1.03 26/02/2012 # I= initial author Rahul Mehta, #II-IV modifications by RRG. You are free to change draft. It will be supported by RRG, if >70% of previous supporters agree on changes. This is just an idea. Authors are not suggesting/forcing any individual/organization /political party to implement it nor to respond to such process nor responsible for any legal issues, if done.)


Attachments:
TCP intermediate measure 4 individual organisations or party.v1.04 26022012.doc [54 KiB]
Downloaded 347 times
Top
 Profile  
 
8
PostPosted: Fri Mar 16, 2012 10:39 am 
Offline

Joined: Mon Oct 17, 2011 2:53 am
Posts: 15
ACTIVISTS, MADE correction as suggested by kmokhsa rahul and others. now all one has to do is print , and type complanit , and sign!! easy to say YES NO . spoonfed... have a look


Attachments:
TCP-intermediate or TOG-in 4 individual organisations or party.v1.05 15032012.doc [110.5 KiB]
Downloaded 317 times
TCP-intermediate or TOG-in 4 individual organisations or party.v1.05 15032012 pdf.pdf [229.16 KiB]
Downloaded 319 times
Top
 Profile  
 
9
PostPosted: Mon Mar 19, 2012 2:46 am 
Offline

Joined: Sun Sep 12, 2010 2:49 pm
Posts: 596
Computechnical guys,

Please give procedure for backup of data, which is cost-effective.

Rest of the modified draft is in attachment along with unclear things highlighted.


Attachments:
TCP-intermediate or TOG-in 4 individual organisations or party.v1.06 15032012.doc [116.5 KiB]
Downloaded 8144 times
Top
 Profile  
 
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 9 posts ] 

All times are UTC + 5:30 hours


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest


You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot post attachments in this forum

Search for:
Jump to:  
cron
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group